Re: KittenAuth Test

The KittenAuth Test, a very cute and brilliant Turing test which could possibly replace CAPTCHA, deserves attention for two reasons: It is much more user friendly than CAPTCHAs, and it can easily be extended with a textual variant, for anyone using a non-graphical browser.

Consider the textual equivalent to the KittenAuth Test: Click on three of the sentences / words which exhibit some property that machines cannot understand without massive manual learning. The text could simply be put as the images’ alt text, and hey presto! An accessible Turing test!

Which language properties could you use? “Hard” words, for example. Which ones of these would you consider “hard”?

  • Kitten
  • Hammer
  • Stool
  • Wall
  • Synonym
  • Paper
  • Ice
  • Fantastic
  • Sugar

“Hammer”, “Wall”, and “Ice”, right? So all you’ll need to do as a programmer is make two lists for each property you’d like to use, and sprinkle the pictures with alt texts from the lists. Naturally, the best place to put the “good” words would be at the same place as the kittens. Then just add a new (CSS hidden) heading to the KittenAuth “gallery” with something like this: “If you cannot see the kittens, please click on three “$property” words instead”. Accessible in a flash…

Update 2006-04-19: Of course, for this to work every user will need a separate, large collection of words tagged with their meanings or categories. In the case of brute-forcing bots, this may be prohibitive. A follow-up post will take up a couple other suggestions.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Re: KittenAuth Test

  1. Ooh, I like that suggestion. At the moment KittenAuth is having problems with pictures sometimes not loading, so I’ll tell Oli to look here next time I see him.

  2. Pingback: Paperless » Blog Archive » KittenAuth follow-up

  3. Pingback: AnySurfer blogt » Blog Archive » CAPTCHA, the sequel

  4. Pingback: Wwohn.com : Captcha alternatives

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s